Buyers Are Renting Instead. Is Your Next Flip Really a Rental?

Here's a number that should change how you underwrite your next deal: a family comfortably renting a single-family home would need about $14,408 more in annual income to own that same house with a mortgage. That's the widest gap since early 2025, and more than double what it was in February.
The buyers your flips depend on haven't disappeared. A lot of them are renting.
Rates are easing, but not enough to bring buyers back.
The 30-year fixed averaged 7.11% as of November 12, the fourth straight weekly decline and the lowest in seven weeks. That's still almost a full point above the 6.24% average from a year ago. And October's inflation report came in hotter than expected, which has the market bracing for another Fed rate hike in December. Don't build your exit around rates falling meaningfully between now and spring.
Resale demand is thin.
Pending home sales are at the lowest level in Redfin's records going back to 2021, and Redfin estimates there are roughly 600,000 more sellers than buyers nationwide. Prices have now slipped four weeks in a row. That's a tougher crowd to sell a finished flip into.
Rental demand is going the other way.
The same affordability squeeze that's shrinking the buyer pool is pushing those households into rentals. Single-family rental demand is running at its highest level in years, and a freshly renovated house in a good school district is exactly what those renters are looking for.
What this means for your next deal:
- Underwrite two exits from day one. Before you buy, run the numbers as a sale and as a rental. If the deal only works one way, know that going in.
- Get real rent comps, not guesses. Check what renovated comparable homes are actually leasing for, and factor in taxes, insurance, and a vacancy cushion.
- Renovate with both buyers in mind. Durable finishes that photograph well serve a retail buyer and a tenant equally. Skip the upgrades that only pay off at resale.
- Decide your trigger point early. Pick the number of days on market, or the price cut, at which you'll switch from selling to renting. Making that call on a schedule beats making it under pressure.
We finance both exits.
At First Funding Loans, our programs are built for fix-and-sell and fix-and-rent investors alike. Approvals are fast, documentation is minimal, and we don't base decisions on tax returns or bank statements. We look at the property and your plan. If a flip turns into a hold, we can talk through the path to refinancing into a long-term rental loan before you ever need it.
If you're looking at a deal right now and want to run it both ways, feel free to reach out. I'm happy to go through the numbers with you.
To your next deal,
Jarrod Fennimore
First Funding Loans
📞 +1 732-991-5216
---
Sources: Zillow rent-vs-own affordability analysis via Investment News (Nov. 13, 2026); Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey (Nov. 12, 2026); U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, October 2026 CPI (Nov. 10, 2026); Redfin Housing Market Update (Nov. 12, 2026). This email is for informational purposes only and is not an offer or commitment to lend. All loans are subject to underwriting and approval.



Comments